Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Local Sports

July 4, 2013

Baseball Debate: Aligning Stars of the Past 50 Seasons

Staff writers break last half-century into three eras



VANKIRK (1980-95)

THE ORDER    BA    HR    RBI    More

1. LF Rickey Henderson    .279    297    1,115    *1,406 SBs*, *2,295 runs*

2. RF Tony Gwynn    .338    135    1,138    8 bat. titles, 15 All-Star

3. CF Kirby Puckett    .318    207    1,085    6 Silver Sluggers

4. 3B Mike Schmidt    .267    548    1,595    8x HR leader, 3 MVPs

5. DH Eddie Murray    .287    504    1,917    3,255 hits, *128 sac flies*

6. 1B Don Mattingly    .307    222    1,099    9 GGs, 442 2Bs

7. 2B Ryne Sandberg    .285    282    1,061    7 SSs, 9 GGs

8. SS Cal Ripken, Jr.    .276    431    1,695    *2,632 cons. Gs*, 2 MVPs

9. C Gary Carter    .262    324    1,225    5 SSs, 11-time All-Star

THE STARTERS    W-L    ERA    More

Roger Clemens    354-184    3.12    *7 CYs*, *20 Ks in game*

Dwight Gooden    194-112    3.51    24-4, 1.53 ERA, 16 CGs in ’85

Nolan Ryan    324-292    3.19    *5,714 Ks*, *2,795 BBs*, *7 NHs*

Fernando Valenzuela    173-153    3.54    Cy Young & ROY (’81), 20 CGs (’86)

Jack Morris    254-186    3.90    175 CGs, 242 IP/season avg.

THE CLOSER    Saves    ERA    More

Dennis Eckersley    390    3.50    Cy Young & MVP in ’92

THE MANAGER    W-L    Pct.    More

Tommy Lasorda    1,599-1,439    .526    4 pennants, 2 WS titles

*=MLB record

The Maynard Era (1964-79)

In my humble opinion, my era would be hard-pressed not to be called the best.

Not because I selected them but, as with any good team, you start with pitching. Who can do much better than Sandy Koufax, Bob Gibson, Denny McLain, Tom Seaver and Jim Palmer? I mean, come on, how many runs could you possibly have to score?

If any of those guys ever got into trouble, we have the intimidating Goose Gossage waiting in the bullpen.

I could stop right there, but I won’t.

Those pitchers will be throwing to the best catcher in baseball history, none other than Mr. Johnny Bench. You will notice that my era is distinctly red in color, as in Redlegs. There’s Joe Morgan, Dave Concepcion and Pete Rose in the infield and a former Red, Frank Robinson, in the outfield. We also have Roberto Clemente and Hank Aaron in our star-packed outfield. Willie “Stretch” McCovey is over at first base and Don Baylor is the DH.

I’ve looked at the other rosters and they’re impressive. But for my money, with the kind of pitching that this era provides, we can’t be beat.

And when it comes to postgame press conferences, who is better than Sparky Anderson?

I rest my case.

Text Only
Local Sports
  • 0724putnamwebshot.JPG Laying the foundation Workers are finishing the foundation for the locker room on the home side of Putnam Stadium on Tuesday. The Ashland Tomcats open the football season on Aug. 22 against Newport Catholic.

    July 23, 2014

  • Genuine throwback

    Todd Eastham is disproving the old cliche, “Those who can, do; those who can’t, teach.”

    July 23, 2014

  • MARK MAYNARD: Looking for those who inspire

    Inspirtation, they say, comes from within. It is defined as an inspiring or animating action or influence.

    July 22, 2014

  • 0722KYPGA_152.jpg Jones tops Gillum in playoff at Eagle Trace

    Ashland senior golfer Logan Jones didn't shoot his average Monday.
    He didn't mind.
    His three-over par 75 and one-hole playoff win over Elliott County junior Ryan Gillum gave him the Boys Open division title in the Kentucky PGA Junior Tour stop at Morehead State University's Eagle Trace Golf Course.

    July 21, 2014 6 Photos

  • 102213_329a.jpg Raceland tabs Clark as new girls basketball coach

    Jason Clark has a reputation of being — to use his word — “passionate” on the Raceland volleyball sideline.
    He plans to bring that same approach as the Lady Rams’ new basketball coach.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0305region2_389.jpg Pass the Mayo: East sophomore PG, Lady Raiders preparing for winter run

    East Carter sophomore point guard Kristen Mayo has played basketball for as long as she can remember.

    July 18, 2014 2 Photos

  • 0718spinda.jpg Steelers super fan Spinda to be recognized in Florida

    Shawn Spinda doesn’t have to use speech to profess his passion for the Pittsburgh Steelers.
    All it takes is a quick glance for a person to get the picture.
    But to absorb the whole picture, you’ll need to clear your schedule.
    Spinda is one of several fanatics who will be recognized at the Sports Fans Conference in Orlando, Florida, which is set for Aug. 28-Sept. 1 at the Walt Disney World Swan and Dolphin Resort. He is a “What a Fan” NFL Fan of the Year nominee.

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0703rfLL0204.jpg Little League State Baseball: Ready to run

    Morehead 11- and 12-year-old All-Star baseball manager Toby Gardner collectively likened his team to a racehorse.

    July 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0717prokick1.jpg Prokicker.com camp Eleven Ashland Tomcat football players were part of the Ray Guy Prokicker.com camp at Huntington High. The high-profile camps are put on all over the country. Rick Sang, an Ashland native who befriended Guy 20 years ago, is the camp's founder.

    July 16, 2014

  • 0716fbpractice0105.jpg Four-down territory: Making summer football practice pit stops

    The popular Monday night catchphrase filled my room on Tuesday morning as my new alarm sounded off at 7 a.m.

    July 16, 2014 5 Photos