Did someone mention a special session?
Already, the Democratic-controlled House and Republican-controlled Senate were pointing fingers of blame over a stalled pension fix and the possibility pension reform will require a special session.
Reflecting what he’s been saying the past couple of days, House Speaker Greg Stumbo, D-Prestonsburg, Friday seemed to think a special session is inevitable and he wants the Senate to take the blame.
“Their actions have indicated they don’t want to address the (pension) issue in a responsible manner and they don’t want to do it in this session,” Stumbo said.
After blaming the House for failing to agree to a pension reform bill sponsored by Senate Majority Leader Damon Thayer, R-Georgetown, which was based on recommendations by a bi-partisan task force, Thayer and Senate President Robert Stivers, R-Manchester, said the House failed to follow the recommendations of that task force.
After the Senate passed Thayer’s bill, the House “gutted” it in Thayer’s words, essentially re-writing the entire proposal and sent it back to the Senate. The House also passed a complex funding plan, based on increased lottery sales and an expansion of instant racing — an issue currently in front of the Kentucky Supreme Court — but with less than 60 votes.
Section 36 of the state Constitution says any revenue or measures require a three-fifths majority (60 votes in the 100-member House, 23 in the 38-member Senate) in odd-year, non-budget sessions.
So the Senate refused to accept the House funding measure. Friday morning, the House sent the Senate a letter saying it was refusing to accept the Senate’s pension bill because it apparently didn’t have an actuarial study when it was passed out of a Senate committee.
But on Wednesday, Stumbo ruled out of order Minority Leader Jeff Hoover’s contention that the House version failed the same test. The House then approved an amended version of the Senate bill which on Friday it told the Senate was out of order.
Reporters Friday were scurrying between the two chambers’ leaders asking where each bill was — in which chamber’s possession in parliamentary language. Stivers had perhaps the best answer for the pension reform bill originally passed out of the Senate.
“It kind of reminds me of purgatory,” Stivers said. “Maybe the public will either pray it in or pray it out.
He and Thayer tried to paint the House as backing out on an agreement reached by the task force which they seemed to think was binding on the legislature.
“The position was established by the committee and we went directly to that position and now the House pulls away from a position that their designees negotiated,” Stivers said.
“What we passed was agreed upon by the task force,” Stivers continued. “So why do they want to change the rules of the game, the practice and procedure right now? It is what all parties agreed to.”
The task force was co-chaired by Thayer and then Rep. Mike Cherry, D-Princeton, who did not seek re-election. When they made their recommendations, the two co-chairs said they thought recommending a funding source to make annual payments into the pension system, the key recommendation, exceeded their jurisdiction.
At the time, they said that is the legislature’s job. They did not recommend no funding source, though Stivers said Friday he recalls the PEW Study for the States consultants who worked with the task force suggested passing the reforms first and dealing with the funding during the normal budget procedure.
House State Government Chair Brent Yonts, D-Greenville, who was a member of the task force and the author of the re-written House version of the Senate bill, said the task force recommendations were never set in stone. He said he didn’t recall the PEW consultants recommending the funding wait.
“The recommendations are a starting point, but they are not the final end game,” Yonts said. “We have two diverging thoughts on what the end game should be.”
Stumbo said it’s irresponsible to pass the pension reforms without a method of paying for them.
Thayer countered that it’s irresponsible not to pass “the structural and systemic changes” now and deal with the costs during next year’s normal budget session.
“You can’t separate them if you want to solve the problem,” Stumbo responded. And then he again said the Senate is likely to cause the governor to call lawmakers back in special session to take up pension reform and tax reform – which might produce new money.
There have been suggestions by some that Gov. Steve Beshear might call a special session to deal with tax reform and pension reform simultaneously.
Thayer and Stivers aren’t enthusiastic about a special session or tax reform.
“There is talk about a special session on tax reform,” Thayer said. “I don’t think we can look the people of Kentucky in the face and say we’re ready to tackle tax reform until we prove to them we’re ready to deal with this big issue.”
Stumbo said he hopes Senate leaders “will take a deep breath” over the weekend and the two sides can negotiate a compromise next week.
Thayer and Stivers said they are ready to work out a compromise.
RONNIE ELLIS writes for CNHI News Service and is based in Frankfort. Reach him at email@example.com. Follow CNHI News Service stories on Twitter at www.twitter.com/cnhifrankfort.
House and Senate pointing fingers over stalled pension fix
Did someone mention a special session?
- Local News
3 indicted in horse shootings
A Boyd County grand jury has indicted three in connection with the shootings of several horses earlier this year.
Government requests imposition of sentences in motorcycle theft ring case
Federal prosecutors have filed a motion requesting that two Ashland men convicted nearly a year ago in a case involving an interstate motorcycle theft ring be sentenced “without further delay.”
Ashland man charged with violating graves
An Ashland man has been charged with grave violation for allegedly stealing brass flower vases from graves in Rose Hill Cemetery, destroying them and selling them for scrap.
Options for Russell zip code change
Seven families living on a short stretch of McCown Street have at least a couple options after the U.S. Postal Service changes their zip code and starts delivering their mail from the Flatwoods post office.
Big Sandy Idol ends with tie — winners crowned
The competition was so great, there couldn’t be one winner of the Big Sandy Idol regional competition.
Local woman’s cookbook No. 1 in South on Kindle
Rebecca Revely never considered herself an author, but her cookbook, “Cooking with Mom,” has started out with a bang on Kindle.
The 33-year-old mother of three self-published the book on March 8, and as of Monday morning it was the No. 1 bestseller in American South Cooking.
Woman reports husband threatened her with gun
A woman living in the 2500 block of Hackworth Street on Friday reported her husband grabbed her by the hair, pointed a pistol at her face and made threats against her life because he was upset over the couple’s pending divorce.
News in brief, 03/11/14
According to a news release from Boyd Commonwealth’s Attorney David Justice’s office, the following defendants were sentenced Friday in Boyd Circuit Court:
ACT rescheduled for Ky. high school seniors
High school juniors in northeast Kentucky and in most districts across the state will take the ACT test March 18, a day that was supposed to be the makeup date.
A few glimpses into House budget plan
Monday is typically a light day in the General Assembly – few committee meetings and a late starting time to allow lawmakers to travel back to Frankfort.
- More Local News Headlines
- 3 indicted in horse shootings