Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Local News

March 10, 2014

Lawmakers get contradictory selenium data

Fish, wildlife official alleges inaccuracies in letter to EPA

FRANKFORT — When lawmakers wrestled last year with new standards for releasing selenium into streams by coal mines and industry, they were assured by state officials the proposals were based on sound science and had been agreed to by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service officials.

But a Dec. 27 letter from Virgil Lee Andrews Jr., the Frankfort field office supervisor for USFAW, to the Region Four office of the Environmental Protection Agency indicates the information given the legislature’s Administrative Regulation Review Subcommittee wasn’t accurate.

Sen. Ernie Harris, R-Crestwood, who co-chairs the subcommittee and voted to approve the new regulation, said the new standard might need another look in light of Andrews’ letter.

“With this new information, maybe we need to look at it again,” Harris said.

Selenium is a chemical found in mineral ores and in trace amounts in the cells of all animals, but it is toxic in larger amounts. It is exposed during excavation or explosions of rock and ore, including surface mining operations.

Kentucky measures selenium in waterways through both an “acute” (immediate) and a “chronic” (ongoing, cumulative) standard. Last year, the Energy and Environment Cabinet’s Division of Water proposed a new acute standard to the subcommittee.

Environmental groups claimed the higher acute standard is toxic and unenforceable and they claimed the Cabinet “cherry-picked” scientific studies to produce the result it desired.

Under the new regulation, when the higher acute threshold is detected it wouldn’t automatically trigger a sanction against the alleged polluter. Instead, the state would test tissue samples from fish and fish eggs to determine if they contained toxic levels of selenium.

But Ted Withrow, a decorated former employee of the Division of Water, told the committee: “If you approve this new acute standard, there won’t be any fish in those streams to test.”

Bruce Scott, commissioner of environmental protection, maintained to lawmakers the new standard was based on solid science and federal Fish and Wildlife officials had signed off on it. The subcommittee approved the new regulation on a controversial split vote.

In his letter to the EPA, Andrews wrote EPA stated in its determination there were discussions and agreement on the criteria between the EPA, the Kentucky Division of Water and the Fish and Wildlife Service.

“This statement is not correct and does not capture the full scope of the discussion,” Andrews wrote. “The service explicitly requested additional review and explanations of the fate and transport of selenium in Kentucky before accepting the (proposed) criteria. Our opinion has not changed on this matter.”

The letter says USFAW is concerned the higher levels of selenium may harm fish and other aquatic wildlife, including federally endangered species, “before fish tissue concentrations ever approach” the new standards.

In an interview last week, Andrews said the service shares the concern expressed to the legislative subcommittee by Withrow, “that by the time some of these triggers happen, the harm will already have occurred.”

He said he never told DOW officials the service was satisfied with the state’s review of scientific literature or the proposed new standards. Scott continues to say otherwise.

“The state consulted and met with Kentucky (branch of the) U.S. Fish and Wildlife staff during the regulation development process during which Kentucky USFAW staff were supportive of Kentucky’s fish tissue approach,” Scott told CNHI News in a written response to questions.

“As USFAW suggests in their consultation letter with EPA, Kentucky DOW conducted a thorough scientific review of the research conducted by nationally recognized experts in developing that criteria,” Scott said.

But Andrews’ Dec. 27, 2013 letter says: “The service strongly recommends that nationally recognized selenium experts review the DOW’s interpretation of the literature and criteria derivation for scientific soundness.”

That seems to bolster Withrow’s testimony before the legislative committee.

“The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service raised grave concerns about the Division of Water’s lack of credible science used to develop the standards for Selenium,” Withrow said last week. The service “fears fish, other aquatic and water dependent species such as birds and amphibians will be poisoned by selenium by the time levels of this pollutant reach the trigger point set by the KDOW standard.”

The contents of the letter took some subcommittee members by surprise, but not Rep. Tommy Turner, R-Somerset, who voted against the new regulation.

“I thought all along it wasn’t right,” said Turner. “They just ran it over us, and this proves it wasn’t right.”

When the regulation was approved last fall, Harris’ subcommittee co-chairman, Rep. Johnny Bell, D-Glasgow, warned Scott he would hold him responsible for the information provided the lawmakers. When told about Andrews’ letter, Bell said he hadn’t forgotten what he told Scott.

“If there’s something going in our waterways that can be shown to be harmful to our people, we’ve got to address that problem in no uncertain terms,” Bell said.

The EPA has not implemented the new selenium standard and environmental groups have sued in federal court to halt implementation. Last week, attorneys for the environmental groups amended the suit to include the information in Andrews’ letter.

RONNIE ELLIS is based in Frankfort and can be reached at rellis@cnhi.com. Follow CNHI News Service stories on Twitter at twitter.com/cnhifrankfort.

 

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Golden Corral sends children to camp

    Ashland’s Golden Corral teamed with other restaurants across nation this year to raise $1.5 million to send a total of 3,000 children to Camp Corral.
     

    July 24, 2014

  • Burglars steal golf gear

    A couple of golf enthusiasts might not make their tee times Saturday because burglars stole golf equipment from their garages.

    July 24, 2014

  • Music instructor claims age discrimination

    The Russell Independent School District is denying allegations of a former band director who claims in a lawsuit the district discriminated against him because of his age.
     

    July 24, 2014

  • Financial blunder leads to heated board discussion

    In a surprising turn of events, City Manager Ben Bitter’s supervision authority was challenged by the Board of Commissioners after Commissioner Cheryl Spriggs filed a motion to have legal and finance department heads also report to the board in light of a financial blunder by Bitter.
    Ashland Mayor Chuck Charles and City Attorney Richard “Sonny” Martin confirmed a new ordinance will be drafted so the department heads of finance and legal counsel will be checked by the board, in addition to Bitter’s current oversight.

    July 24, 2014

  • Stricter enforcement, diagonal spots endorsed to help downtown

    A group of business owners operating along Winchester Avenue — Ashland’s main thoroughfare — asked the Ashland Board of Commissioners to replace current parallel parking spots with diagonal ones, and also for more strick enforcement of a two-hour parking law.

    July 24, 2014

  • National act takes stage at Boyd County Fair

    The Building of Dreams erupted into screams Thursday night at the 2014 Boyd County Fair, as country music fans saw Bucky Covington take the stage.
    According to Ellen Keaton, fair board president, Covington was a favorite on season five of Fox’s talent competition series American Idol.

    July 24, 2014

  • Smoke-free advocates bound for Ashland

    Advocates for smoke-free public spaces are touring the state, starting in Ashland, to drum up support for anti-tobacco legislation they hope to pass next year.
    Smoke-Free Kentucky is a coalition of organizations and people who support a ban on smoking in all public and work places in Kentucky.

    July 24, 2014

  • Ohio State Band Direc_Mayn.jpg Ohio State marching band chief fired after probe

    Ohio State University fired the director of its celebrated marching band on Thursday after determining he ignored a "sexualized" culture of rituals including students being pressured to march in their underwear and participate in sexually themed stunts.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Grimes has pep rally before energetic Democrats

    Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Alison Lundergan Grimes was preaching to the Democratic choir Thursday night at the Wendell Ford Dinner attended by about 700 here.

    July 24, 2014

  • Commissioners challenge city manager’s authority

    In a surprising turn of events, City Manager Ben Bitter’s supervision authority was challenged by the Board of Commissioners after Commissioner Cheryl Spriggs filed a motion to have legal and finance department heads also report to the board in light of a financial blunder by Bitter.

    July 24, 2014

Featured Ads
Seasonal Content
AP Video
Arizona Prison Chief: Execution Wasn't Botched Calif. Police Investigate Peacock Shooting Death Raw: Protesters, Soldiers Clash in West Bank Police: Doctor Who Shot Gunman 'Saved Lives' 'Modern Family' Star on Gay Athletes Coming Out MN Twins Debut Beer Vending Machine DA: Pa. Doctor Fired Back at Hospital Gunman Raw: Iowa Police Dash Cam Shows Wild Chase Obama Seeks Limits on US Company Mergers Abroad Large Family to Share NJ Lottery Winnings U.S. Flights to Israel Resume After Ban Lifted Official: Air Algerie Flight 'probably Crashed' TSA Administrator on Politics and Flight Bans Raw: National Guard Helps Battle WA Wildfires Raw: Ukraine's Donetsk Residents Flee Senators Push to End Hamas Threat in Cease-Fire A Young Victim's Premonition, Hug Before MH17 Raw: Deadly Storm Hits Virginia Campground Death Penalty Expert: 'This is a Turning Point' Raw: MH17 Victim's Bodies Arrive in Netherlands
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
AP basketball
SEC Zone