Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Local News

December 5, 2013

Settlement reached in Coach trademark infringement suit

ASHLAND — A settlement agreement has been reached in a federal lawsuit filed by a New York-based leather goods manufacturer against a Carter County businessman and former political candidate over the sale of knockoff versions of the manufacturer’s products.

According to a joint status report filed Tuesday in U.S. District Court by attorneys representing Coach Inc. and Coach Services Inc., the plaintiffs in the suit, and David K. Hayes of Grayson and Hayes & Co. LLC, doing business as Hay Mart, the parties have reached an agreement to settle all claims in the matter.

Terms of the settlement were not disclosed.

Judge David L. Bunning ordered the parties to file a proposed agreed order of dismissal by Dec. 20. The case had been scheduled to go to trial March 10.

In the suit, filed in May 2011, Coach accused Hayes and his company of trademark and trade dress infringement, unfair competition and trademark dilution. The company sought damages equivalent to $2 million per infringement, or, in the alternative, all of the profits Hayes & Co. reaped from selling counterfeit Coach products.

According to the lawsuit, on Dec. 8, 2010, Coach purchased from Hayes and Co. a black fabric-and-leather handbag “bearing at least four marks subject to Coach registered copyrights and trademarks” for $50. The average retail price for a comparable authentic Coach item is $298, the suit states.

An inspection by Coach revealed the bag was counterfeit and infringed on Coach’s intellectual property for a number of reasons, according to the suit. However, the company said while it found the bag bore a number of similarities to an actual Coach item, the product contained uneven stitching and other flaws and did not meet Coach’s quality standards.

At the time of the handbag purchase, Hayes & Co. also was selling approximately 20 other imitation Coach items, including handbags and wallets, the suit states.

Hayes & Co. has never been an authorized retailer or manufacturer of Coach products, according to the suit. The lawsuit alleges Hayes and Co. has used, and is continuing to use “spurious designations that are identical to, or substantially indistinguishable from” Coach’s trademarks.

Those actions “are likely to create a false impression and deceive consumers, the public and the trade into believing that there is a connection or association between the infringing products and Coach,” the suit states.

Coach was founded more than 60 years as a family-run workshop in Manhattan. Today, the company’s annual worldwide sales total more than $3 billion, according to the suit.

Hayes, who has run for state representative and for Carter County judge-executive, denied Coach’s allegations in a response to the lawsuit.

Hayes’ sister, Sandra Seagraves, also is a defendant in the suit. She filed a counterclaim accusing Coach of “outrageous and aggressive” conduct, which was dismissed in April of last year.

KENNETH HART can be reached at khart@dailyindependent.com or (606) 326-2654.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • 0723trailtown.jpg First lady recognizes Morehead Trail Town status

    Kentucky first lady Jane Beshear said Morehead’s achievement in finally reaching “Trail Town” certification exemplifies the strength and dedication of the small town community during her address Tuesday at the Rowan County Arts Center.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • McConnell co-sponsors bill to protect correctional officers

    U.S. Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell co-sponsored legislation to help protect correctional officers and staff at Federal Bureau of Prison (BOP) facilities.

    July 22, 2014

  • 0723copshots1.JPG Focus on law enforcement

    Members of several local and regional law enforcement agencies hit the streets of downtown Ashland Tuesday armed with digital cameras and assignment sheets as they completed in-service photography instruction through the Department of Criminal Justice.

    July 22, 2014 3 Photos

  • Obama admin. says health subsidies will continue

    A federal appeals court delivered a potentially serious setback to President Barack Obama's health care law Tuesday, imperiling billions of dollars in subsidies for many low- and middle-income people who bought policies.

    July 22, 2014

  • State’s longest trail system turns 35

    The Sheltowee Trace was officially dedicated as part of the National Recreation Trail system in 1979. After 35 years, the trail remains Kentucky’s longest distance trail, estimated at 307 miles.
     

    July 21, 2014

  • Pancake releases new album

    The top of the Sky Tower in downtown Ashland was booming Saturday night with music from Larry Pancake’s new album “Fair Weather Friend.”
     

    July 21, 2014

  • Telephone scammer fleeces man of $5,000

    A telephone scammer claimed another area victim when a Williams Avenue man paid $5,000 after the con artist told him he had won a sweepstakes but had to pay taxes on the prize money before collecting it, according to Ashland Police Department reports.
     

    July 21, 2014

  • Murder defendant pleads guilty on lesser charge, sentenced to 8 years

    One of four charged with murder in a 2008 double killing pleaded guilty to a lesser charge Monday just before his trial was to start.

    July 21, 2014

  • MIA Rush Marine to rest in Arlington

    Finding Dottie McCoy’s uncle after 71 years was the biggest part of the struggle.

    July 21, 2014

  • Morehead gets Trail Town status

    It has been two and a half years in the making and it happens today.
    Morehead will officially be designated a Kentucky Trail Town following Dawson Springs and Livingston.

    July 21, 2014