Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Local News

April 30, 2014

Jury: Layoffs weren't politically motivated

CATLETTSBURG —  The Boyd Fiscal Court’s January 2011 decision to lay off five county employees was motivated by finances, not politics, a Boyd Circuit Court jury ruled on Wednesday.

The seven-man, five-woman jury deliberated for only about an hour before returning a verdict in favor of the fiscal court and Boyd Judge-Executive William “Bud” Stevens, the defendants in the wrong-termination suit filed by the five.

The verdict capped off a three-day trial in Judge C. David Hagerman’s court.

In ruling for the defendants, the jury rejected the claims of the plaintiffs — Leslie May, Michelle “Missy” Miller, Angie Durham, Matt Shelton and Tim Knipp — that they were discharged because they were perceived of supporting in the November 2010 general election.

The three women and Shelton all claimed their layoffs were political payback by Stevens because he believed they supported former Boyd Road Foreman Keith Robinette, Stevens’ Republican opponent in the election. Stevens, a Democrat, defeated Robinette by only 14 votes to win a second term. It first appeared Stevens had lost by a nine-vote margin, but he prevailed after additional votes that hadn’t been tabulated were later discovered.

Knipp alleged he was laid off at the behest of County Commissioner David Salisbury because he is related by marriage Mark Bell, Salisbury’s Republican opponent in the 2010 general election.

Stevens isn’t running this year for a third term as judge-executive. Salisbury is a candidate for the Democratic nomination for judge-executive.

The women all testified that Stevens had referred to them as “back-stabbers” and warned them their jobs were in jeopardy for not supporting his candidacy. Stevens denied ever making such statements.

May, Shelton and Knipp all worked under Robinette at the county road department. Shelton and Knipp were subsequently recalled and continue to work for the county. May, Durham and Miller all have found other jobs, but for less money and lesser benefits than what they were receiving as county employees.

Durham worked as the county’s payroll and human resources supervisor and Miller was in charge of administering the payroll and net profits tax. Their positions, along with May’s, were eliminated.

The plaintiffs also alleged the layoffs were not done in accordance with the county’s personnel policy, which dictates that seniority be considered when choosing employees to lay off, and that laid-off employees be given first shot at future job opportunities for which they are qualified.

The plaintiffs were among 17 county employees who were furloughed by the fiscal court in January 2011. Attorney Bruce Leslie, who represented Stevens and the fiscal court, told jurors the layoffs were done out of financial necessity because the county was facing a severe fiscal crisis at the time, with not even enough money on hand to meet its payroll. He also said eliminating Miller’s and Durham’s jobs and outsourcing their duties had saved Boyd County’s taxpayer’s $355,000 to date.

The county farmed Durham’s duties out to Huntington Bank for $11,000 a year — less than a third of Durham’s salary — and transferred the job of administering the payroll tax to County Clerk Debbie Jones’ office. Jones charged the fiscal court $2,500 per quarter for the service, but, according to Stevens, the court receives that money back at the end of the fiscal year in the form of excess fees.

Stevens declined to comment on the verdict, saying he preferred to let Leslie speak for him. Leslie said he believed his clients had been “vindicated” by the jury’s decision.

“Judge Stevens has always had the best interests of the taxpayers of Boyd County at heart,” he said, adding that laying off workers wasn’t something the fiscal court wanted to do, “It was something they had to do.”

Plaintiffs’ attorney Gordon Dill declined to comment on the verdict.

The plaintiffs were seeking compensation for lost earnings and up to $500,000 each for emotional pain and suffering.

Civil trials in Kentucky, unlike criminal ones, do not require unanimous verdicts, only for nine of 12 jurors to agree. However, Hagerman said each of the verdict forms was signed by the jury foreman, indicating the decisions were unanimous.

KENNETH HART can be reached at khart@dailyindependent.com or (606) 326-2654.

Text Only
Local News
  • 0728bank5.jpg Gate City landmark demolished

    The historic Catlettsburg National Bank Building was being taken down after the front dormer window collapsed on Sunday.

    July 28, 2014 4 Photos

  • Local counties see drop in unemployment

    Boyd County was one of 117 counties that saw a decrease in its unemployment rate between June 2013 and June 2014.

    July 27, 2014

  • 0726bigboy.JPG Big Boy to open Aug. 11

    The long-awaited Frisch’s Big Boy restaurant will open Aug. 11, and when it does it will be business as usual from day one: the eatery will open its doors to the early breakfast crowd at 6:30.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • SOAR meeting at MSU Aug. 6

    Morehead State University and St. Claire Regional Medical Center will present Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and U.S. Rep. Hal Rogers as part of a "Health Impact Series" under the new Shaping Our Appalachian Region initiative.

    July 27, 2014

  • MSU moving business admin. program online

    Morehead State University’s School of Business Administration has announced its bachelor of business administration degree in computer information systems has moved totally online beginning the fall 2014 semester.

    July 27, 2014

  • Thefts, fraud reported to APD

    The following information was taken from Ashland Police Department reports:

    July 27, 2014

  • Raceland couple join Peace Corps

    A couple from Raceland will travel to the Republic of Botswana on Aug. 10 to begin training as volunteers in the Peace Corps.

    July 27, 2014

  • Missing Boyd inmate returns to jail

    The Boyd County inmate who walked away from a work detail on Saturday turned himself back in to the Boyd County Detention Center on Sunday.

    July 27, 2014

  • 0728MoreheadMusic_1457.jpg Hills alive with Old Time Music

    The hills surrounding Morehead were alive again this weekend with the sounds of fiddles, banjos and deep Appalachian voices that help keep old time mountain music alive in a modern world.

    July 27, 2014 2 Photos

  • Bill Clinton coming to eastern Kentucky to stump for Grimes

    CNHI News Service

    GLASGOW — Democrat Alison Lundergan Grimes is again calling in the “Big Dog” in her quest to unseat five-term Republican U.S. Sen. Mitch McConnell.

    July 27, 2014