|
Published: February 18, 2008 11:09 pm
Motorcycle suit moved to federal court
By KENNETH HART
The Independent
ASHLAND —
A lawsuit filed last month by a group of motorcycle owners that claim their bikes were illegally seized by the Kentucky State Police as part of a criminal investigation has been moved from state to federal court.
An order was entered recently transferring the case from Boyd Circuit Court to U.S. District Court in Ashland.
The main reason the case was transferred is it involves questions of whether the plaintiffs’ Constitutional rights were violated, said Catlettsburg attorney Garis Pruitt, who filed the suit on behalf of the motorcycle owners.
In the state court complaint, the three name plaintiffs, Mark Justice, Terry Elliott and Pete Withrow, all of Ashland, claimed their cycles were among about 45 seized from owners in and around Boyd County last summer by the KSP and FBI.
Each of the seizures was done “without a warrant and without court permission” and were outside the scope of the KSP’s statutory authority, the complaint alleged.
The suit names as defendants the KSP and William Riley, a detective with the agency’s Lexington-based Special Investigations Section.
In its response to the suit, the KSP acknowledged seizing the bikes and it continues to hold them. However, the agency denies the vehicles were wrongly taken from their owners and maintains it acted within the scope of Kentucky law.
The KSP also states the cycles were seized “in conjunction with a joint interstate criminal investigation” with the FBI.
In an amended complaint filed in federal court, Pruitt maintains that by seizing the motorcycles without warrants and without giving the owners the opportunity to contest the seizures, the KSP violated the owners’ rights to due process of law under the Fourth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution.
Also, Pruitt argues the state law the KSP cites to justify the warrantless seizures “is unconstitutional both on its face and so applied.” Similar laws permitting warrantless seizures of private property based solely on police officers’ beliefs have been struck down as unconstitutional in other states, the complaint states.
The suit was filed in federal court on behalf of the three named plaintiffs and “42 others similarly situated.” Court records also indicate Justice is no longer part of the case.
KENNETH HART can be reached at khart@dailyindependent.com or (606) 326-2654.
• Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Physician’s Assistants and Nurse Practitioners
VA MEDICAL CENTER
The VA Medical Center Huntington, WV, is recruiting for these positions to work in the ...>MORE
LPN and/or MEDICAL ASSISTANT
Needed for busy practice. Must have office exp. Send resume & salary req. to Box 01251, c/o The Independent, PO Box 311,...>MORE
CARRY OUT PERSON
Must be 21 yrs. old. Apply Shamrock Liquors, 1117 13th St., Ashland....>MORE
See all ads |
| Premium Cars, RVs and Boats |
HARLEY DAVIDSON FOR SALE
2001 Heritage Softail show ready! Must see! $15,000 obo. 324-2680....>MORE
MIATA FOR SALE
2004, Ltd Ed, silver/blue, hard top, a/t, $18,000. 606-922-8300....>MORE
JAVELIN BOAT FOR SALE
JAVELIN- ‘97, 18’, 150hp, new sonar. GPS, trolling motor, ex. cond, $10,500 Call (606)325-8029....>MORE
See all ads |
|
LOAD, KY ACREAGE
8-10 acres, Little White Oak Rd. top Bentley Cem. hill. 473-6633....>MORE
GREENUP CO. HOMES FOR SALE
3BR, 2BA, $49,500; 2BR, 1.5BA, $45,000. (606)473-2061....>MORE
ASHLAND HOME
MUST SEE HOME FOR SALE BY OWNER Located at 725 14th St. Newly renovated. Near KDMC. Price $177,899. 740-...>MORE
See all ads |
|
SHIH-TZU/LHASA PUPS
Gorgeous, ready to go! $200. 606-474-5062....>MORE
HONDA 400 4 WHEELER
‘02, 1 owner, low miles, $2,500. 606-928-2083....>MORE
FARM TRACTOR
FARM TRACTOR- diesel, 72 in. Woods grooming mower, ex. con. 831-0451...>MORE
See all ads |
|
 |
|