Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Editorials

October 9, 2013

Devastating

Closing of Big Sandy plant will eliminate scores of jobs

ASHLAND — The fact that we have been anticipating — no, make that fearing or dreading — for months that the Kentucky Public Service Commission would approve Kentucky Power Co.’s purchase of half interest in a West Virginia power plant does not make it any easier to take. The decision clears the way for the eminent demise of much of the Big Sandy Power plant near Louisa.

 For the life of us, we still can’t see much that is positive in this decision for the people in the 20 eastern Kentucky counties served by Kentucky Power.

Oh, to be sure, Kentucky Power customers will see their rates go up by “only” 14 percent by purchasing half interest in the Mitchell Power Plant just south of Moundsville, W.Va., as opposed to the 26 percent rate hike that would have been required to add scrubbers to the Big Sandy plant to bring it into compliance with federal Environmental Protection Agency air quality standards.

As far as Kentucky Power officials are concerned, the 12 percent difference between the rates needed to buy half of the Mitchell plant and bring the Big Sandy plant into compliance clearly make purchasing the Mitchell plant the best option as far as area consumers are concerned. And if you only consider the impact the PSC’s decision will have on what area customers pay for electricity, the PSC made the right decision.

But this decision is not just about what we pay for electricity. It is about the loss of approximately 150 of the highest paying and most reliable industrial jobs in Lawrence County because of the downsizing of the power plant. It means the coal industry in this region, which already has seen the loss of hundreds of high-paying mining jobs disappear, will see more jobs eliminated as one of the region’s the biggest coal customers ceases to need coal. It means that dozens of truckers who for years have made a good living transporting coal from the mines to the power plant will see their jobs disappear.

It means the loss of approximately $1 million a year in tax revenue for both Lawrence County government and the Lawrence County School System. At the very least that means the elimination of dozens of jobs for teachers and other school employees and for county employees. Even worse, it means that the school system will lack the funds to adequately educate children and county government won’t be able to afford to provide essential county services

No wonder State Rep. Rocky Adkins, who as majority leader is one of the most powerful members of the Kentucky House of Representatives, called the PSC’s decision  “disappointing and devastating,”  

While PSC officials insisted that considering the “arguments on economic benefits to specific areas of Kentucky Power’s service territory are beyond the scope of the commission’s jurisdiction,” the commission directed Kentucky Power to “more than double the amount of shareholder money it had voluntarily agreed to spend on economic development” in the area to offset those job losses and reductions in coal use by the Big Sandy plant.

The commission will require Kentucky Power to spend at least $233,000 in each of the next five years on economic development with $33,000 going to training programs through the Kentucky Community and Technical College System focused on weatherization and energy efficiency.

We’re all for spending more on economic development but we question how training people on weatherization and energy efficiencies is going to create many of the type of jobs this region will need to replace the number of good-paying industrial and mining jobs and high-paying mining jobs that will be lost by the closing of the Big Sandy plant. What we fear is that the Kentucky Power money will be used to train area residents for jobs that will force them to move to find work. Out-migration already has cost this region too many of its best and brightest young people. The PSC’s decision will only make the problem worse.

How is closing the only large generating plant in eastern Kentucky going to enhance economic development in this region? It seems that would-be employers that require a lot of electricity won’t give this region a second look.

All area elected officials were united in protesting the PSC’s decision,

Daniel Kemp, a spokesman for Attorney General Jack Conway, expressed disappointment, saying the attorney general is “exploring our legal options regarding the ruling.”

“Kentucky Power did not thoroughly evaluate other options available to it, such as purchasing the power on the market from other electric utilities,” said Kemp. “Additionally, the company did not conduct an economic feasibility study, as the law requires, to determine whether its ratepayers could afford the increased rates that will result from this plan.”

The PSC’s decision really dates back to 2007 when Kentucky Power agreed under a federal court consent decree to close an 800-MW coal-fired unit at the Big Sandy facility by mid-2015 unless it was upgraded to meet stricter carbon emissions standards. Even if KPC changed its mind and agreed to upgrade the Big Sandy plant, it’s unlikely the necessary changes could be made by 2015.

 The decision also incorporates an earlier agreement by KPC and two intervening groups, the Kentucky Industrial Utility Customers, Inc., and the Sierra Club, to freeze rates until May 31, 2015. It removed a provision, however, permitting KPC to pass onto ratepayers $28 million in costs to study whether to upgrade Big Sandy.

 Adkins said he will ask the PSC to reconsider its decision.

  “I don’t think there was a fair calculation of what is the lowest cost option,” Adkins said. “I’m thoroughly convinced putting scrubbers on at Big Sandy is the low-cost option in the short run and the low-cost option over the next 30 years.”

What supporters of the Big Sandy plant now need more than ever are facts to support the opinions of Adkins and others. If they can’t be supplied, then we fear the PSC’s decision will stand.

1
Text Only
Editorials
  • Deadline is near

    People with Kentucky driver’s licenses may soon be required to show a passport or some other accepted form of federal identification to enter “restricted” or “semi-restricted” areas of federal facilities, including federal courthouses, military bases, federal prisons and a wide range of other federal offices.

    July 23, 2014

  • Issue is safety

    The Kentucky High School Athletic Association’s Board of Control has recommended softball  “players at first base, third base and pitcher utilize the permissive requirement in the playing rules and wear face/head protection.”

    July 23, 2014

  • More difficult

    In a state like Kentucky with the number of adults who have not graduated from high school is much higher than the national average, undereducated adults have been encouraged to earn high-school equivalency degrees by studying for, taking and passing the General Educational Development (GED) test.

    May 22, 2014

  • Primary election sends messages

    The voters — or at least the minority who took the time to go to the polls Tuesday — have spoken, with Boyd County voters sending mixed messages in the county-wide races that gathered the most attention.

    May 21, 2014

  • Click it or Ticket

    "Click it or Ticket” is a phrase used so often in recent years most of us hardly give it a thought.

    May 21, 2014

  • Top trooper

    Thumbs up to Trooper First Class Shane Goodall of Flatwoods for being named 2013 Trooper of the Year for Kentucky.

    May 20, 2014

  • 05/18/2014 — This Week in the Tri-State

    Local news

    May 18, 2014

  • 0518greene.jpeg Greene-Lounsberry

    John and Eva Greene of Greenup are proud to announce the engagement of their daughter, Stacey Nicole Greene, to Jonathan Wesley Lounsberry.

    May 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Business grant

    Morehead State graduate student Kayla Keeton, who received her undergraduate degree from MSU last spring and is now studying for her MBA at the school, has received a $5,111 grant from the Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development to help her start Belles of the Bluegrass, a high-tech wedding planning business.

    May 16, 2014

  • Recovery Fest celebrates kicking addiction

    The wet weather no doubt impacted the size of the crowd at Saturday’s Recovery Fest 2014 at Veterans Riverfront Park in Ashland, but there were plenty of reasons for addicts who are now drug free to celebrate and for speakers like State Sen. Robin Webb, D-Grayson, and others to talk about the impact the prescription drug epidemic has had on this region and for others to distribute literature and offer words of encouragement that could convince some to seek help in their battle with their drug addictions.

    May 13, 2014