Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Editorials

June 24, 2013

Going too far

High court unanimously agrees confession was coerced

ASHLAND — Police officers in Todd County were so over-the-line in their questioning of Garrett Thomas Dye in connection with the beating death of his 9-year-old sister, that the Kentucky Supreme Court unanimously voted to overturn Dye’s conviction for the murder. That decisions does not necessarily mean Dye, who is serving 50 years in prison, will automatically be freed. But it does mean that Dye will receive a new trial.

Investigators repeatedly threatened Dye, then 17, with the prospect of execution and being sexually assaulted in prison unless he admitted to the beating death of his sister, Amy Dye. Their tactics resulted in a coerced confession, the Kentucky Supreme Court ruled. In addition to granting a new trial for Dye, the state’s highest court ordered a trial court to determine if evidence collected based on the statements should be allowed at the trial.

“Not only did the officer erroneously convey that (Dye) was death-eligible, but also that he was certain to receive a death sentence unless he confessed to his sister’s murder,” Justice Will T. Scott wrote. “We hold that repeatedly threatening a 17-year-old with the death penalty is objectively coercive.”

The impact of the ruling extends beyond this one case by placing limits on what investigators may say to teenaged suspects during an interrogation.

Scott also concluded four officers made “inappropriate allusions” to prison violence and rape throughout the interrogation. “Everybody’s gonna forget about you until you get to Eddyville then they’ll remind you of what happened. Every day they’ll remind you,” an officer told Dye.

“We will not feign ignorance to the fact that the officers were alluding to prison violence and-or rape and that is precisely how (Dye) understood these comments,” Scott wrote.

The girl’s death drew the attention of state lawmakers. Records in the case were eventually released showing social workers either ignored or dismissed allegations of abuse and neglect against the child.

Amy Dye went missing Feb. 4, 2011, after spending the afternoon with her brother shoveling gravel. Police found the body early the next morning in a thicket about 100 yards from the Dye home. Investigators confiscated shovels, clothes, shoes and took a DNA swab from Garrett Dye.

Dye’s father told officers he didn’t want the teen questioned without an attorney present and he was released. Police arrested Dye the next day and charged him in the slaying.

During four hours of interrogation, police repeatedly told Dye he would be executed for killing his sister with a jack handle. But Dye could not have been executed under a U.S. Supreme Court decision barring the death penalty for anyone under 18 at the time of a crime. The officers also didn’t disclose that Dye couldn’t have received a death sentence because there were no aggravating factors to the slaying, which is required under Kentucky law to bring a capital case.

The officers repeatedly told Dye he would be sexually assaulted and possibly beaten in prison if he went to death row at the Kentucky State Penitentiary at Eddyville. Dye at one point said he wanted to speak with a lawyer. Officers later told Dye if he chose to speak with a lawyer before talking to them, he would lose an opportunity to tell the truth.

Those threats and omissions were enough to overcome Dye’s will and ability to make a rational decision about whether to talk to investigators, Scott wrote. Based on Dye’s statement, officers returned to the house and seized more evidence, including shovels and other yard working equipment. The admissibility of those materials at trial should be decided by a judge, Scott wrote.

Whether Garrett Thomas Dye killed his sister is not the issue here. It is whether police used improper tactics to coerce a confession. Every member of the Kentucky Supreme Court is convinced they did. Because of their actions, Dye will get a new trial. He deserves one.

1
Text Only
Editorials
  • What's next?

    While virtually all cities in northeastern Kentucky provide their residents with some utility services — water and sewer, mainly, and sometimes natural gas — to the best of our knowledge, Olive Hill is the only town in the FIVCO‚Äąregion with its own electrical company.
     

    April 13, 2014

  • 'Waited too long'

    Lt. Garlin Murl Conner left the U.S. Army as the second-most decorated soldier during World War II, earning four Silver Stars, four Bronze Stars, seven Purple Hearts and the Distinguished Service Cross for his actions during 28 straight months in combat.

    April 12, 2014

  • Enact HB 3

    The National Rx Drug Abuse Summit is under way hundreds of miles from eastern Kentucky in Orlando, Fla., but the three-day conference which runs through Thursday, was organized by Operation UNITE, the eastern Kentucky anti-drug group that knows all too well the devastating impact the prescription drug epidemic continues to have on this region.

    April 11, 2014

  • State officials cease efforts to stop advance of ash borer

    Kentucky’s war against the tiny emerald ash borer responsible for already killing more than 25 million ash trees in the eastern United States has ended in surrender — by state officials, not the tiny insect.

    April 8, 2014

  • Demise of apparel industry in Kentucky continues

    The steady demise of the once thriving clothing industry in small Kentucky towns continues with the latest factory to announce it is shutting down being one of the largest: Fruit of the Loom has announced it is closing its last remaining plant in Jamestown, a move that eventually will see the elimination of more than 600 jobs in the small town near Lake Cumberland.

    April 7, 2014

  • None on ballot

    The 2014 Kentucky General Assembly considered an unusually high number of proposed amendments to the Kentucky Constitution on such issues as casino gambling, the restoration of voting rights for convicted felons and the elimination of state and local elected offices.

    April 4, 2014

  • Time runs out

    Two bills proposed by House Majority Leader Rocky Adkins and designed to boost the economy of this region have apparently died in the Kentucky Senate after being approved by the House of Representatives. Despite easily being approved by the Democratic-controlled House, neither bill was even brought up for a vote by the Republican-controlled Senate.

    April 2, 2014

  • Time runs out

    Two bills proposed by House Majority Leader Rocky Adkins and designed to boost the economy of this region have apparently died in the Kentucky Senate after being approved by the House of Representatives. Despite easily being approved by the Democratic-controlled House, neither bill was even brought up for a vote by the Republican-controlled Senate.

    April 2, 2014

  • Dismal numbers

    The good news is that the health ratings of all but two area counties improved in the latest ranking of the state’s 120 counties. However, before we pat ourselves on the back for those improvements, the overall health of residents of counties in northeast Kentucky remains rather dismal. Yes, we are improving but we still have a long, long way to go.

    April 2, 2014

  • Kentucky losing many of its old barns

    Many of those of us who are old enough to remember traveling on two-lane highways  have fond memories of the role barns played in keeping us informed. By reading advertisements painted on roadside barns, we learned about Mail Pouch chewing tobacco and Rock City and Lookout Mountain in Chattanooga, Tenn.

    March 26, 2014