Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)


February 9, 2013

Creative decision

Appeals court ruling expands definition of a ‘violent crime’

ASHLAND — Benji Antonio Stout never touched another person when he scaled a fence in 2005, ducked through a hole and sprinted away from the Lincoln County Detention Center. But the U.S. District Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday that Stout’s escape properly amounted to a “crime of violence” and upheld the longer prison term he received for another crime Stout committed.

How can a crime in which no one was touched and violence was not even threatened be considered a violent crime? Well, according to Judge Edmund Sargus, the escape amounted to a crime of violence because “it is natural to infer a significant risk that an inmate will resort to violence rather than being recaptured.”

A divided appellate court cited the escape in upholding Stout’s 2010 conviction and 12-month federal prison sentence for possession of body armor by a person convicted of a violent crime.

Sargus, joined by Judge R. Guy Cole, found 8 percent of escaped inmates commit violent offenses against guards in the process of getting away. That prospect renders the escape a violent crime, Sargus concluded.

“Our holding today is not based on a broad speculation as to the future events that might occur after the crime,” Sargus wrote. “Rather, it is based on the substantial risk that offenders who choose to escape from secured settings will engage in physical violence during the course of the escape.”

Judge Bernice Bouie Donald dissented, citing notable fictional escapes in “The Count of Monte Cristo” and “The Shawshank Redemption” and pointing out the getaways by the characters Edmond Dantes and Andy Dufresne involved acts of violence, when all Stout did was scale a fence and run through a hole he didn’t make.

“Something is missing here — perhaps it is common sense,” Donald wrote.

Stout has an extensive criminal history involving both state and federal convictions, but none of his crimes had involved violence. On Aug, 4, 2009, police in Winchester stopped Stout and found four pieces of body armor in his car. After being indicted, Stout challenged the violent crime designation, but a judge rejected his arguments.

Stout pleaded guilty in 2010 in federal court in Lexington to the body armor charge in exchange for several drug-related counts being dismissed by prosecutors. A judge sentenced him to a year in federal prison. Stout appealed the violent crime designation.

Sargus wrote that escape from a secure jail doesn’t involve a risk of “simply accidental injury,” but a likelihood of the inmate using violence to get away while being detected and confronted.

“In other terms, given the serious consequences that result from capture, it is likely that many offenders will not simply give up their escape if they encounter security,” Sargus wrote.

In  his dissent, Donald said when Stout left the jail, “his crime was complete.” He added that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2010 that a violent crime must involve “a substantial degree of force.”

“Keeping this in mind, it is not farfetched to say that climbing a wall or crawling through an open hole does not ordinarily involve a ‘substantial degree of force’,” Donald wrote.

Given his criminal history, it is difficult to have much sympathy for Stout, but based simply what he did  — and not on speculation of what he might of done if given the opportunity — the escape was not a crime of violence. From our viewpoint, Judges Sargus and Cole erred in their ruling; Judge Donald got it right.

Text Only
  • By a thread

    It took some last-minute political maneuvering by State Rep. Tanya Pullin, D-South Shore and some skilled wheeling and dealing to prevent a bill important to AK Steel in Ashland from ending up on the scrapheap of the 2014 Kentucky General Assembly.

    April 23, 2014

  • Along the river

    Here’s hoping the weather will be as close to perfect as possible on the evening of May 30, as members of the Paul G. Blazer High School class of 2014 gather on the banks of Ohio River for the school’s first graduation on the river that has helped fuel this community’s economy since the time when it was known as known as Poage’s Landing.

    April 22, 2014

  • Good opportunity

    Morehead State University is using a highly successful program for outstanding high school juniors and seniors at Western Kentucky University to launch a similar program beginning in the fall of 2015 on the MSU campus.

    April 20, 2014

  • What's next?

    While virtually all cities in northeastern Kentucky provide their residents with some utility services — water and sewer, mainly, and sometimes natural gas — to the best of our knowledge, Olive Hill is the only town in the FIVCO region with its own electrical company.

    April 13, 2014

  • 'Waited too long'

    Lt. Garlin Murl Conner left the U.S. Army as the second-most decorated soldier during World War II, earning four Silver Stars, four Bronze Stars, seven Purple Hearts and the Distinguished Service Cross for his actions during 28 straight months in combat.

    April 12, 2014

  • Enact HB 3

    The National Rx Drug Abuse Summit is under way hundreds of miles from eastern Kentucky in Orlando, Fla., but the three-day conference which runs through Thursday, was organized by Operation UNITE, the eastern Kentucky anti-drug group that knows all too well the devastating impact the prescription drug epidemic continues to have on this region.

    April 11, 2014

  • State officials cease efforts to stop advance of ash borer

    Kentucky’s war against the tiny emerald ash borer responsible for already killing more than 25 million ash trees in the eastern United States has ended in surrender — by state officials, not the tiny insect.

    April 8, 2014

  • Demise of apparel industry in Kentucky continues

    The steady demise of the once thriving clothing industry in small Kentucky towns continues with the latest factory to announce it is shutting down being one of the largest: Fruit of the Loom has announced it is closing its last remaining plant in Jamestown, a move that eventually will see the elimination of more than 600 jobs in the small town near Lake Cumberland.

    April 7, 2014

  • None on ballot

    The 2014 Kentucky General Assembly considered an unusually high number of proposed amendments to the Kentucky Constitution on such issues as casino gambling, the restoration of voting rights for convicted felons and the elimination of state and local elected offices.

    April 4, 2014

  • Time runs out

    Two bills proposed by House Majority Leader Rocky Adkins and designed to boost the economy of this region have apparently died in the Kentucky Senate after being approved by the House of Representatives. Despite easily being approved by the Democratic-controlled House, neither bill was even brought up for a vote by the Republican-controlled Senate.

    April 2, 2014

Featured Ads
Seasonal Content
AP Video
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
SEC Zone